I was at the Garden last night to see U2 in their last New York concert of the year. It was my first time seeing them live and, excepting a real downer of a finale, the show was everything I hoped for. Seeing U2 now is something like watching the 1998 Yankees, if you'll forgive the sports analogy. A seasoned and talented team of professionals approaching each night with something to prove, executing each and every play to perfection and giving their fans more than their money's worth each and every time they take the stage. For you, it might be the 72-10 Bulls or the 85 Bears, but whatever picture you draw make it one of a group of men at the absolute pinnacle of their profession. That's what U2 is. I remember the first time I became aware of the band, it was via MTV and the video for "Sunday Bloody Sunday." If you don't remember it, it was the early 80's, a live concert at Red Rocks, the air smoky and the music loud, passionate and in your face. In that guise they remind one of Michigan's Fab Five, going places no one could imagine on the back of raw talent and instinct. Last night was more refined and wholly professional, but like the 98 Yankees, you can never hide the passion and fire that gives birth to performances for the ages.
The show started red hot, grabbing a lively crowd right from the get-go. "City of Blinding Lights" was the first song, followed in short order by "Vertigo" and "Elevation." Bono played the role of general, confidently surveying the surroundings, strutting far and wide to be sure that everyone knew who was in charge of the situation. The Edge was his Sgt. at arms, leading each one of the assaults on the crowd and Adam Clayton and Larry Mullen played the foot soldiers doing the dirty work necessary to vanquish another arena and add yet one more notch to Bono's impressive bedpost. The stage was like a 5th bandmember, its elliptical shape reaching deep into the crowd festooned with video screens, electronic lights and assorted other doodads. Again the Yankee comparison rears it's head, with the non-Bono bandmembers doing the same jobs that Paul O'Neill, Bernie Williams and Tino Martinez used to do, all on a stage that added drama and resonance, just like Yankee Stadium does every time a game is contested within its walls.
The opening trio of songs was followed by "The Electric Co." off of "Boy," the first U2 album all the way back in 1980. It was amazing to think, watching them tear through the song at Madison Square Garden that they had probably first played it in a basement in Dublin. In general it is unthinkable that the rowdy, scruffy group from that "Sunday Bloody Sunday" video is now the slick, massively famous band we see today. Even more incredible is, even with that meteoric rise, the band has been able to keep a link with their fans most similar to Bruce Springsteen. People still see Bono as one of them with a voice, much like Springsteen has kept the blue-collar appeal that he had first starting out. It's most evident during "Sometimes You Can't Make It On Your Own," when Bono removes his shades to sing the song he wrote about his late father. It is a completely calculated moment, the rock star who is always wearing sunglasses removing them to show his emotional involvement in that particular tune but I'll be damned if it doesn't work in spades. The song is moving and powerful, thanks in no small part to the lack of spectacles on the singer. He hit another strong emotional note during "Pride (In The Name Of Love)" by changing some lyrics to point out that JFK was assassinated on the same date 42 years prior.
The concert rocked on, through "I Still Haven't Found What I'm Looking For," "Beautiful Day," "Bullet the Blue Sky" and others from the most recent album. The highlight for me was when they ripped into "Sunday Bloody Sunday," mixing it halfway through with "Rock The Casbah" before going back into the original tune to close the song out. Believe me when I say even Sharif would have liked it. Along the way Bono hit on everything you'd expect him to; the aforementioned sunglasses removal; telling us America was not a country but an idea which the whole world believes in; and a plea to help Africa. Again, he's a rockstar, but you can't help believing that he is being honest and forthright when he says these things and that ability to connect with people was never more clear to me than last night. The set proper ended with his Africa appeal and, naturally, "One" before the band left to prepare for the encore.
The encore, unfortunately, is where the band ran into a bit of trouble. The trouble didn't start right off the back as they played a stirring "With Or Without You" and brought the house down with a chilling "Stuck In A Moment You Can't Get Out Of." Bono and The Edge performed it as an acoustic duet and the song was lovelier than it's ever sounded to me before, particularly the higher vocals which The Edge sings in a voice you wouldn't imagine coming from a man named The Edge. It was interesting that they dedicated the song to Michael Hutchence, the deceased frontman of INXS who had died on the date 8 years prior. He passed away, of course, due to strangulation caused by a belt around his neck cutting off oxygen while he pleasured himself. It's interesting because the song was "Stuck In A Moment You Can't Get Out Of" which is about as good as it gets for a tabloid headline about Hutchence's death. Beautiful song, maybe a little on the nose for this particular tribute.
All of this was building to what, I think I'm safe in saying, everyone in the arena believed would be a showstopper of an ending. Bono told the crowd that the next song would be a cover of a song by someone synonymous with New York City and when he invited opening act and 70's punker Patti Smith on stage I assumed we were going to hear a Ramones song before a proper U2 sendoff. Instead the band ventured forth with a shaky and surprisingly uncertain cover of John Lennon's "Instant Karma." The shakiness was made worse by a very cracked out looking Patti Smith slurring and mumbling her sections of the song and a fairly uninspired performance from the band itself. Bono eventually helped Smith off the stage, following her down the stairs before, I hoped, returning for the final song of the evening. But the band followed soon after, only to return for 30 or so seconds more, with an even more bewildered looking Smith, of "Karma" before leaving once again. The crowd was confused, as it felt like a very abrupt ending, chanting "U2, U2" in a dark arena for a few minutes before the house lights came up and we all shuffled home.
I hate to go back to the sports analogy well but the first thing I thought of while leaving was Game 4 of the 2003 World Series. To recap, Joe Torre resisted putting Mariano Rivera in to pitch in a tie game, even as it moved into extra innings. The Yankees eventually lost the game when Jeff Weaver gave up a home run to Alex Gonzalez and Torre rightly took criticism for losing a game without using his best pitcher. Last night U2 did the same thing, they had "40," "Bad," "Running to Stand Still," "I Will Follow" and several others in the bullpen, but instead they turned things over to Jeff Weaver, or Patti Smith in this case, and left without using all the weapons at their disposal. It was a disappointing ending, as even George Costanza knows that you want to go out on a high note, but not enough to overshadow what was 2+ hours of greatness before that point.